After waiting until the flurry of spring semester (and the drudge of grading) wore off, I’ve finally begun Marilynne Robinson’s long-awaited, Pulitzer Prize-winning second novel. Months ago when I first bought Gilead, I was disappointed by its opening: the book didn’t “grab” me in the way that Housekeeping had. In retrospect (and in all fairness to Robinson), I don’t believe Housekeeping grabbed me immediately, either. Robinson’s prose is careful and poignant, its charms developing softly and slowly.
Gilead is well-crafted, but it doesn’t shimmer like a jewel. Instead, its beauties are simple and ordinary, like those of a well-worn quilt. The story of a dying preacher as told to his young son, Gilead captures the vision of a person who’s been on this earth long enough to recognize wonder in the simple things: a couple of rowdy men laughing, a mother blowing bubbles with her child.
It’s no wonder that passages of Robinson’s novel remind me of the plain, simple goodness of Tom Montag’s memoir, Curlew: Home. Tom’s proud of the fact that he’s a farm boy from Iowa, and although Robinson was born and raised in Idaho, Gilead, which takes its title from an Iowa town of the same name, shows that her stint teaching at the University of Iowa has not been in vain, the prose and perspective of that state rubbing off on her in the best of ways.
Jul 1, 2005 at 11:36 am
And THAT is the way to write a book review! Anyone that can make me “feel” the story without telling me the story the way you just did deserves an award.
Is there such an award for book reviewers? You deserve one; thank you.
Jul 1, 2005 at 5:09 pm
A minister friend of mine was reading “Gilead” last time I saw him, and he seemed to be loving it. Given the confluence of his recommendation and yours, I shall add it to my wishlist post haste — along with Tom’s book, which I didn’t know about, but which I am delighted to hear exists…
Jul 1, 2005 at 9:32 pm
Thanks for the thumbs-up on Gilead. I’ve read a number of reviews, all positive, for the book, but none made me want to jump out of my chair to find it at the library the way yours does.
I liked Housekeeping when I eventually read it. It had been assigned in college and I found it didn’t lend itself to the frantic reading pace the syllabus required. Much more of a downtime summer read, when you have time to savor the language and the lessons the book is trying to teach.
Jul 2, 2005 at 7:33 am
Les, I don’t know if anyone gives book review awards…but in all honesty I have to admit that I didn’t give away any of the story because I haven’t read far enough to have discovered any spoilers!
Rachel, definitely read *Gilead*, and *Curlew,* too, while you’re at it. I initially had a difficult time getting “into” *Gilead*, I think, because I couldn’t help but make comparisons with *Housekeeping*: it’s one of my all-time favorite novels, so I was bound to be disappointed starting something that *wasn’t* it. But now that I’m reading taking the time to treat *Gilead* as its own work, it’s bearing its own reward.
It also took me a while to get “into” *Curlew*, but for other reasons. On the one hand, it’s so place-based & personal, I felt like an outsider awkwardly trying to get to know the place; on the other, I felt a bit embarrassed having an inner look on Tom’s childhood!
BUT, that awkwardness quickly dissolved once I realized the narrative was *trying* to make me feel simultaneously “at home” and alien. By book’s end, I was loving a landscape I’ve never seen, which is the true goal of any memoir, I think.
Sprite, I know *EXACTLY* what you mean when you note that *Housekeeping* requires a slow read. I assign HK in one of my lit classes, and I always feel guilty because we only have 2 weeks to read & discuss it. At the same time, though, I first read it (hurriedly) in a grad class, so I would have never returned to *re-read* it if it weren’t for that initial speed-read. Some books are just meant to be re-read, and HK is one of them.
I’ve heard others say the same thing about *Gilead*…I’ll know better once I’ve finished it!
Jul 2, 2005 at 10:46 am
Lorianne–thanks for the plog, and for the good words. It humbles the ol’ Iowa grumble-bear to hear you say such things. And gladdens his heart, I might add!
It’s interesting that in a book titled CURLEW: HOME, it is a full third of the way into the book before I arrive at Curlew. I think that reflects the reality of trying to go home: a lot of it is simply the “getting there.”
Jul 6, 2005 at 4:49 am
You’re welcome, Tom. Robinson has a passage in which the narrator describes a storm tearing the roof off a chicken house, and that’s when I stopped reading & realized the echoes I was hearing from *Curlew.* And I agree about the “trying to get home” phenomenon. While you were trying to get home, I as reader was trying to get over my internal awkwardness at being invited into a place that was “home” for you but unfamiliar to me. It takes a while, but we all get there eventually.