It’s been just over a week since we put Reggie to sleep, and I’ve noticed that the tears now come unbidden and unexpectedly, inevitably when I least expect them.
I can do the dishes most mornings now without looking out on the dog pen and weeping, after having spent so many mornings checking for Reggie outside before our morning walks, wondering over the previous night’s dishes how long we’d make it at his slow, unsteady pace before turning back for home. I can, most mornings, do yoga in Reggie’s favorite resting spot–a sun-soaked segment of hardwood floor that still feels like it’s “his”–without tears streaming down my face like the first few mornings. And I can meditate now in the spot where Reggie’s food and water bowls used to be–a spot that feels empty and open now, somehow perfect for meditation–without tears, just gratitude for another sunny morning with open windows and birdsong, and the memory of the countless times I’d meditated in my apartment in Keene with Reggie lying a few feet away, waiting for me to be done with sitting so we could get down to the business of walking.
The times I might expect to weep for Reggie, in other words, aren’t necessarily when the tears come. When I get home from campus on Tuesday and Thursday nights, for instance, I now know not to look for Reggie lying in the bedroom as I ascend the stairs to the second floor: I know to brace myself for his empty spot. But it’s those random moments when I’m not expecting to be broadsided by grief that catch me unprotected, like this morning when I was folding laundry and casually caught a reflected glimpse in the mirror of the Empty Spot where Reggie used to lie, or those moments in the middle of the night when I get up, half asleep, to go to the bathroom, taking care not to step on a dog who is no longer there.
This morning I found myself suddenly weeping over a passage in Diane Ackerman’s A Slender Thread, which I’m still reading (slowly) after having first mentioned it here last December. Ackerman describes a visit to Walt Whitman’s birthplace in Long Island, which leads her to recount the familiar story of how Whitman volunteered as a nurse during the Civil War, providing companionship and comfort to injured and dying soldiers. It was Ackerman’s description of Whitman embracing one soldier while telling him that death is nothing to fear that drove me to tears, the image of one soul helping another go gentle into that good night ringing too close to home. How great a gift it is to provide companionship to the dying, and how great a mystery is dying itself?
I’ve learned–I’m learning–to be gentle with myself during this tender and tenuous time, recognizing that just as Reggie’s final days were precious because I made a conscious effort to be mindful of every moment, so too do these days of grief deserve their own attention. I’m learning not to fight anything: not the tears, not the memories, not the moments of sadness, relief, or gratitude. Whatever arises, I try not to fight it; I try not to judge it; I try just to watch it, open-eyed and attentive. I tell myself not to miss even a moment of this experience, because this too has worth and value: an emotional legacy that cannot and should not be denied.
I’m learning to be gentle with myself…and having learned to be a little gentle, I continually learn how to be even more gentle, letting go, gradually, of how I think grief should be or how it ought to progress. If you cast aside even the notion of “process,” all you’re left with is this present moment, this present emotion, this present teardrop, none of which has an exact comparable, ever.
Apr 18, 2012 at 7:22 pm
Oh Lorianne, I am so sorry, and I hear how hard it can be. And yes, be gentle with yourself.
LikeLike
Apr 18, 2012 at 7:41 pm
Yes, I’m learning how to be gentle with myself, just as I learned how to be gentle with Reggie as he aged. It’s a matter of giving myself the care I gave him.
LikeLike
Apr 18, 2012 at 7:49 pm
After our first dear dog died, I realized he must always have been colliding, rubbing, leaning against me just below my knee on the outside of my leg because I felt the physical absence of that like a phantom limb. The empty place where a dog was is so surprising and real.
LikeLike
Apr 18, 2012 at 7:59 pm
Sometimes it seems to me that grief for animals is much purer and more poignant than for people. When people die everybody else’s emotions are jostling with yours, and so often there’s unfinished business of one sort or another, there’s legacies and ceremonies and stakes how they’re going to be remembered. But with our pets, it’s just the loss, pretty much straight up.
You gave Reggie so much joy. You two took so much joy together. It was lovely to see.
LikeLike
Apr 18, 2012 at 8:34 pm
You’re very wise in your grief. My thoughts are with you as you adjust to your loss.
LikeLike
Apr 18, 2012 at 8:57 pm
Saturday I saw a terrier that looked so much like my last one, same markings, same grooming style, same facial structure, coloring, and expressions. I spoke to his owners and inquired about him. I reached down to touch him, and several tears slid down my cheeks while I tried to ignore them. His owners looked at me and said, “Oh, how long has it been since yours passed on?” I said, ” eleven years.” Both of them seemed surprised, obviously expecting me to answer in months or at least many fewer years. Quickly, the woman followed with, “It looks like it is time to get another dog!” I smiled, and we walked on. Of course, I knew that a new pet will never prevent the tugging at my heart which very rarely but still can surface despite these years when I recall his face and the way he cocked his head, the way he tumbled against my side when wanting to wake me, or some other memory that belongs to only the two of us.
LikeLike
Apr 18, 2012 at 9:25 pm
Gentle with yourself, yes. And yes to everything you say here about the mystery and the wonder of being with someone as they pass over from this life to whatever comes next. In the fullness of time I wish you comfort, my dear, along with all who mourn.
LikeLike
Apr 18, 2012 at 11:21 pm
So sad for your loss. Despite how right we know the time is, and how good to ease the journey of a faithful friend, it’s hard on those left behind. Thank you for the post about Reggie’s final journey. I cried along with you remembering all the happy times read here.
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2012 at 2:09 am
Lorianne, I understand completely. I cried spontaneously for at least two weeks after we put Ernie and Ruby down, at unpredictable moments. I like your comments about letting go of ideas about how grief should progress, and what the process should be. That seems like a very healthy approach, to just feel what you’re feeling.
I’m not sure whether I will help or hurt the situation by saying that I still miss our dogs, especially every night when I get into bed and they’re not there. I even dreamed about them last night. I suppose in that sense they’re still with me, just as Reggie, in some ways, is still with you.
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2012 at 12:07 pm
Thanks, everyone, for the comments. I’m realizing now that the process of “being with” Reggie as he aged was a kind of training for “being with” the process of letting him go now that he’s gone. I’m remembering the early days after my divorce and how that process didn’t match what I’d expected it to be: it was an emotional roller-coaster ride you simply had to take moment-by-moment. I suspect all losses are like this: you can try to brace yourself, but you’re never prepared.
With the divorce, I sometimes compared it to losing a limb: you eventually get used to life with one leg, but you never really “forget” or “get over” the fact that you once had two. Again, I’m realizing that this applies in the context of grief, too. You can “move on” from grief, but you never really “get over it.”
LikeLike
Jul 9, 2012 at 11:36 am
I know how you feel… Next July 12 there was a year that Flora passed away… I miss her everyday… My thoughts are with you, Lorianne.
LikeLike