Ever since Rachel announced the Progressive Faith Blog Con she’s planning along with a handful of other spiritually minded bloggers, I’ve been sitting with a question. What makes a Zen blog?
Although I don’t talk about Zen much here on Hoarded Ordinaries, if you click my “About” links, you’ll see I practice and teach Zen meditation. I sometimes blog Zennish oddities like my eclectic and oh-so-festive meditation altar, I blogged the passing of Zen Master Seung Sahn, and I occasionally talk about meditation retreats and visits to my Zen school’s head temple. One of these days, I want to resume posting to my currently inactive meditation blog, and I’ve already mentioned that one of my non-resolutions this year is to practice more, relying on the community of meditators at 100 Days to keep me motivated.
Despite these Zennish jots and tittles, though, I was surprised to discover that if you do a Technorati Blog Finder search for zen, Hoarded Ordinaries is listed as the third most authoritative site. Third? Considering all the practitioners who actively and explicitly talk about their meditation practices–bloggers such as John and Robert and Kimberly–it seems absurd to see humble HO as being a Zen authority. Even before the blogger-formerly-known-as-Andi ditched the raft, her laywoman’s blog was far more Zen-rich than mine…and now that she’s a postulant in a Buddhist nuns’ temple, Soen Joon’s new blog has more Zen in its first five posts than Hoarded Ordinaries has in two years of posts combined.
For good or ill, I have an odd resistance to talking much Zen here on my blog. It’s not that I’m hiding my practice, for evidence that I meditate is there for anyone wishing to look for it. But whereas many of the bloggers I read write blogs that focus on their Zen practice, I write a blog that looks at practice only tangentially. Just as I love taking blind pencam shots that look at the world askance, I prefer to talk about meditation by not talking about it.
Knowing that no words can truly describe what it’s like to meditate or what it’s like to be “in” the present moment, I choose to sidestep the discussion almost entirely. If you want to see my Zen, you won’t see it emblazoned boldly like the sign for a downtown Northampton restaurant. Instead, if you want to see my Zen, you’ll have to walk around with me a while, looking where I look and seeing what I see. Perhaps there’s a hint of Zen in the sleek lines and refreshing colors of a bright-lit shop display…or maybe not. But I suspect that wherever you look to find your Zen, you won’t see it looking back at you in any sort of bold, emblazoned fashion. Instead, you’ll probably see it lurking in a corner, quiet and almost forgotten until an open eye looks its way.
I guess I’ve always considered Zen and the enlightenment it presumably seeks as being an inherently now-you-see-it, now-you-don’t sort of proposition. If I were to point to something Intrinsically Zen here on my blog, that Zen would presumably disappear by the time you or any other reader happened to look that way, too. Instead of wasting words and pictures trying to show you my Zen, I’d prefer you found your own, thank you. There’s an ample supply of it out there, you see. And you don’t need a Technorati Blog Finder to point you toward it.
- There is indeed a Zen Center on Main Street in Northampton, MA, but I walked right by it. Instead, the sign that heads today’s post is from an Asian restaurant down the street that has a much more obvious sign.
Jan 2, 2006 at 8:06 pm
If, as you say, there are many more blogs that put their Zen “out there”, why is yours so near the top in the search engine? That it is near the top, is very interesting.
I like that your Zen is quieter, so to speak. I think it shows a practice of Zen that is so engrained as to not need shouting about, which is the way any practice of the sort should be.
LikeLike
Jan 3, 2006 at 12:41 am
Lorianne, I think I like your Zen *because* it’s quiet! And as for your New Year’s non-resolutions…consider one book already sold. 🙂
LikeLike
Jan 3, 2006 at 11:02 am
this was a really great post, lorraine. good questions. what is not zen? i started my “zen blog” as a way to sit down at the end of the day to organize my thoughts of mindful living. knowing that others may read them held me accountable in terms of expressing myself clearly (plus the act of writing and dialoging is fun). but then six months later i have asked myself the exact same questions you raise. sometimes i write and i edit myself for being “off topic” and i ask “what the heck does that mean anyway.” thanks for the thought-provoking post.
LikeLike
Jan 3, 2006 at 12:11 pm
Hi–This actually has nothing to do with this post, but…I saw this in the paper and I thought you’d be interested. Maxine Kumin will be giving a poetry reading tonight at NEC. It will be at the Simon Center at 7. I thought it was appropriate after our class! Hope you are well.
LikeLike
Jan 3, 2006 at 12:45 pm
What makes a Zen blog?
Discipline, grasshopper, discipline.
🙂
LikeLike
Jan 3, 2006 at 5:04 pm
Ah but Lorianne, as one who practises mediation and has my own zen moments, I feel zen in you everytime I look at your nature pictures. You have a “quiet” aura about the whole thing and I like that.
LikeLike
Jan 3, 2006 at 11:01 pm
kenju, I think that Technorati rating says something about the Blog Finder mechanism works. When I listed HO under my Technorati profile, I entered various keywords to describe it, and “Zen” was one. Apparently many folks haven’t “tagged” their site in this manner…and the fact that I have a relatively old blog with lots of posts means I “look” more authoritative than a newer site with fewer posts.
But the blog that’s ranked *first* is a tech blog with “zen” in the title, so the ranking isn’t based on whether you actually talk about Zen or not.
Soen Joon, I will personally sign & mail you the first copy as soon as it’s off the press. How’s *that* for some Noisy Zen? 🙂
Kimberly, I certainly enjoy zen-themed blogs…but for whatever reason, I don’t find myself having a lot to *say* on one. I started a practice blog some months ago, and at some point I want to return to it…but for now, I feel like focusing on my writing & photography is how I “do Zen” in my artistic life. So although I practice on mat & cushion, I don’t have much to say about that; my creative work is where I “show” my Zen, so to speak.
Angela, I bet that poetry reading is part of the creative writing program at NEC, isn’t it! Several years ago when I lived in Hillsboro, NH, I went to see Anne Waldman give a *very* spirited reading at NEC right around this time of year: they sponsored an entire week of readings.
I actually saw Kumin do a reading in Concord, MA several years ago, after she’d just recovered from the spinal injury she suffered several years ago. She’s quite powerful in person!
I chuckled, Kathryn, at your comment. It kind of reminds me of that old joke, “How do you get to Carnegie Hall?” “Practice, practice, practice!”
Jude, I’d like to think my writing & photography are “most Zen” when I stand out of the way & let the words & images speak for themselves. So it’s good to hear at least some readers feel the same way.
LikeLike
Jan 6, 2006 at 11:35 am
Lorainne,
Don’t get hung up on Technorati’s use of the word “authoritative.” The folks at that commercial site are interested in all blogs, not in judging content.
As they say rather clearly, by “authoritative” they mean they rank blogs by in-links and the keyword that you, the blog claimant, provides.
So, since you have selected Zen [and Buddhism, too] as one [two] of the twenty keywords you are permitted to choose, you make the list for a tag search of that word[s].
Your ranking has absolutely everything to do with your number of in-links from other blogs. This will be influenced by the number and quality of your posts, the general appeal of your blog, the number of friends you have and the times you’ve been on the cover of People magazine.
My blog, Blogmandu, the Buddhism metablog, uses the Technorati authoritative rankings for fun, posting a table of the most-authoritative Buddhism blogs in a post from time to time. Your blog is borderline, but has been excluded from our subset rankings on a technical — and admittedly imprecise, but useful — basis that most of the tags you have chosen have nothing to do with Buddhism.
Your blog is wonderful, of course, but by my humble estimation it is not a Buddhism or Zen blog. At the same token, had you chosen the word ‘Communist’ as one of your tag words, it would not, presto-chango, make your blog a Communist blog. On the other hand, it is certainly OK, by any measure, to include Zen and Buddhism as your keywords. Your blog is sure to be of interest to a great many Buddhist blog readers. Tagging your blog as you have will be helpful to blog readers in finding your blog with all its wit, wisdom, humanity and overall top-notch quality.
So. There you have it.
LikeLike