Our house has been playing Christmas music all November, and one of the songs in random rotation is a cover of Dolly Parton’s “Hard Candy Christmas.”
Maybe I’ll dye my hair
Maybe I’ll move somewhere
Maybe I’ll get a car
Maybe I’ll drive so far they’ll all lose track
Me, I’ll bounce right back
The original is, of course, better–folks shouldn’t even try to cover Dolly’s songs since her versions will always be better–but still, the song is noteworthy regardless of who sings it because it is a prime example of a rare phenomenon: a song that passes as a Christmas song without being artificially upbeat and forcibly cheerful.
Maybe I’ll sleep real late
Maybe I’ll lose some weight
Maybe I’ll clear my junk
Maybe I’ll just get drunk on apple wine
Christmas is a complicated time: the season is unabashedly joyful for some but bittersweet or even downright tragic for others.
I’ll be fine and dandy
Lord, it’s like a hard candy Christmas
I’m barely getting through tomorrow
But still, I won’t let sorrow bring me way down
I’ve written before about Vince Guaraldi’s instrumental version of “Christmastime Is Here,” a song that is poignant and powerful precisely because it captures Charlie Brown’s existential loneliness during a season where everyone else is painfully happy.
Hey, maybe I’ll learn to sew
Maybe I’ll just lie low
Maybe I’ll hit the bars
Maybe I’ll count the stars until dawn
Me, I will go on
”Hard Candy Christmas” captures a similar mood. The song isn’t actually about Christmas, except for the mention of the holiday in the title.
Maybe I’ll settle down
Maybe I’ll just leave town
Maybe I’ll have some fun
Maybe I’ll meet someone and make him mine
Instead, the song is about trying to find one’s way in the face of disappointment and heartbreak.
I’ll be fine and dandy
Lord, it’s like a hard candy Christmas
I’m barely getting through tomorrow
But still, I won’t let sorrow bring me way down
The singer’s life is “like a hard candy Christmas” insofar as she is trying to put a brave face on heartbreak, resolving to be “fine and dandy” even as she’s “barely getting through tomorrow.” “Hard Candy Christmas” is a song about soldiering on, and I love that it slips under the radar of obligatory Christmas cheer.